Blog Flux Directory Subscribe in NewsGator Online Subscribe with Bloglines http://www.wikio.com Blog directory
And, yes, I DO take it personally: Calling Iraq's mess a "civil war" is NOT a moral judgment
Mandy: Great blog!
Mark: Thanks to all the contributors on this blog. When I want to get information on the events that really matter, I come here.
Penny: I'm glad I found your blog (from a comment on Think Progress), it's comprehensive and very insightful.
Eric: Nice site....I enjoyed it and will be back.
nora kelly: I enjoy your site. Keep it up! I particularly like your insights on Latin America.
Alison: Loquacious as ever with a touch of elegance -- & right on target as usual!
"Everybody's worried about stopping terrorism. Well, there's a really easy way: stop participating in it."
- Noam Chomsky
Send tips and other comments to: profmarcus2010@yahoo.com /* ---- overrides for post page ---- */ .post { padding: 0; border: none; }

Monday, December 11, 2006

Calling Iraq's mess a "civil war" is NOT a moral judgment

according to juan cole, it's a social science question...
First-rate Iraq historian Sarah Shields argues that Iraq is not having a civil war so much as it is living through the consequences of the US having destroyed its functioning state. I agree with her that the framework for the fighting was set by Rumsfeld/Cheney/Bush policies in Iraq. But you could say that and still admit that they are now fighting a civil war. The latter is a social science question, not a moral judgment. Avoiding the appearance of a moral judgment of a negative sort that might attach also to the US effort is also the reason that the Right won't call it a civil war.

excellent points, all... the u.s. did indeed create a civil war in iraq by its invasion and what was done - and not done - subsequently... disregarding for a moment that it was an illegal, unprovoked invasion, by failing to factor in that we were taking the lid off of a pressure cooker, thus opening a pandora's box of violence and death, we most certainly are responsible for what is going on now... calling it a civil war is not a moral judgment... creating the conditions for hundreds of thousands of people to die unnecessarily IS...

Submit To Propeller


And, yes, I DO take it personally home page