Oh, those annoying and inconvenient "imaginary privacy concerns"
read this and then tell me if you think these "privacy concerns" are "imaginary"...
here's the money quote - "it turns family members into genetic informants without their knowledge or consent"... no shit... and there's NOTHING IMAGINARY about that kind of concern...
Tweet
[S]tates are moving to conduct familial searches of criminal databases, looking for close-to-perfect matches with DNA from crime scenes. A partial match with a convicted criminal could implicate a brother or daughter or father of the convict. Such searches, advocates say, constitute a powerful law enforcement tool that, experts say, could increase by 40 percent the number of suspects identified through DNA.
As things stand in some states, lab analysts who discover a potential suspect in this way may not be permitted to share that information with investigators. Such a policy, said William Fitzpatrick, a New York state district attorney, "is insanity. It's disgraceful. If I've got something of scientific value that I can't share because of imaginary privacy concerns, it's crazy. That's how we solve crimes."
But the technique is arousing fierce objections from privacy advocates, who maintain that it turns family members into genetic informants without their knowledge or consent. They complain that it takes material collected for one purpose and uses it for another. And with the nation's DNA database disproportionately comprised of minority offenders, they say, it amounts to placing a class of Americans under greater scrutiny merely because their relatives have committed crimes.
"If practiced routinely, we would be subjecting hundreds of thousands of innocent people who happen to be relatives of individuals in the FBI database to lifelong genetic surveillance," said Tania Simoncelli, science adviser to the American Civil Liberties Union.
here's the money quote - "it turns family members into genetic informants without their knowledge or consent"... no shit... and there's NOTHING IMAGINARY about that kind of concern...
Labels: 4th Amendment, ACLU, BTK killer, DNA testing, U.S. Constitution
Submit To PropellerTweet